Hlavní navigace

Názor ke zprávičce Wikipedie debatuje nad obrázky v článku Rorschachův test od Lol Phirae - Aha, tak toto jsou vedecke metody. Vis, kdyz fyzik...

  • Aktualita je stará, nové názory již nelze přidávat.
  • 16. 7. 2009 7:25

    Lol Phirae (neregistrovaný)

    Aha, tak toto jsou vedecke metody. Vis, kdyz fyzik vyvine „metodu“ mereni, ktera v 16 z 18 pripadu bude produkovat zcela irelevantni data bez jakekoliv vypovidajici hodnoty, tak se mu ostatni vysmeji. Kdyz totez udela psycholog, tak to je „vedecka metoda“.

    A abych to nejak uzavrel, tak bych jeste jednou citoval:

    Rorschach proponents sometimes express surprise, dismay, or irritation that their inkblots excite strong controversy among research-oriented clinical psychologists. However, the reason is not hard to find: From the time of Lee J. Cronbach, Hans Eysenck, and Joseph Zubin up until the present, legitimate scientific criticisms of the test have been adamantly resisted or ignored by Rorschach proponents (for a historical summary, see Wood, Nezworski, Lilienfeld, & Garb, 2003). So long as proponents continue to dismiss legitimate criticism, ignore negative research, and present the test as the psychological equivalent of medical imaging techniques, the Rorschach is destined to remain on the fringes of psychological science.